All six are about access rather than quality. A page can be excellent and fail every one of them.
01Can it be found?
Every page needs a link from somewhere a crawler already visits. A page reachable only from a search box, a dropdown that needs JavaScript, or nowhere at all is effectively unpublished.
The term: orphan pages. Common after redesigns.
02Is it allowed to be fetched?
A single misplaced line in robots.txt can exclude a whole section. It happens most often when a staging rule survives the move to production and nobody checks.
Takes: minutes to fix, months to notice.
03Does the HTML contain the content?
If the page arrives empty and fills in through JavaScript, indexing depends on a rendering pass that is slower, delayed and less reliable than reading HTML.
Affects: most single-page applications by default.
04Is it allowed to be indexed?
Noindex tags, canonical tags pointing somewhere else, and conflicting signals between the sitemap and the page itself. Individually small, collectively decisive.
Frequent cause: a plugin default nobody reviewed.
05Is it worth indexing?
Thousands of near-identical filter and pagination URLs dilute a site. Search engines index a subset and choose which — and the one they pick is often not the one you wanted.
The term: index bloat. Faceted navigation is the usual source.
06Does the old URL still work?
Every redesign retires URLs. Without redirects, the links and rankings those pages accumulated are discarded — and the visitor gets a 404 instead of the thing they clicked.
Cost: permanent, and entirely avoidable.